Nathan Oakley: Why the Globe Needs a Flat Earth
Why does Nathan Oakley say the globe needs a flat Earth? The host of Flat Earth Debate and author of Measured Flat: All Roads Lead to Flat Earth joins Chance Garton to lay out his argument that the globe model is built from measurements of a flat plane. Starting with the vocabulary of science itself, observation, measurement, calculation and experiment, Nathan argues that the word science has been hijacked to lend the feel of proof to a cosmology that rests on flat geography.
From there the conversation works through his housekeeping questions: what an elevation angle actually measures, how sailors fix a position from Polaris and a sextant, why the lines of latitude on a globe are a protractor wrapped around you, why north is a horizontal direction rather than up, and why the molten iron core and the Theia impact story look to him like cognitively expensive distractions. The two close on fear as the signal to go looking for a lie, and on why a simpler picture of the world lets you sleep easier.
Plus+Full episode · 2h 5m
InnerVerse Plus+Hear the full 2h 5m episode
57 more minutes of this conversation, plus the complete Plus+ archive, premium video and a private podcast feed for your app.
Cancel any time.
Get tuned with Chance
Tuning forks find where energy is stuck in the field around your body and bring it back into flow. Sessions over Zoom, recorded for you to keep.
30 Minute Consultations
Have something to look at, or looking for guidance? We can consult oracular tools, read your chart, or just talk through whatever you choose.
In this episode
Core themes
Science Hijacked to Sell the Globe
Nathan Oakley opens by arguing that the public has been hijacked with science: the vocabulary of an empirical method, words like experiment, empiricism and science itself, gets borrowed to lend proof to claims that were never tested, from rocket trips through sky vacuums to the ball model taught in school. He compares it to the old shampoo advert where a woman flicks her hair and the voiceover announces that now comes the science part. Chance Garton adds that many astrophysicists quoted in Measured Flat admit their field does not use the scientific method, and suggests listeners examine the framework beneath a claim before bothering with the claim itself.
Elevation Angles and the Globe as Protractor
Nathan Oakley describes elevation angles as one of the principal ways Earth is measured, and claims the lines of latitude on a toy globe are really a glorified protractor wrapped around the observer. In his account, celestial navigation means measuring the angle to a known star with a sextant, subtracting from ninety, multiplying by sixty to get nautical miles, and drawing a circle of equal altitude; where three circles intersect is your fix. Chance Garton points out that none of this trigonometry works if any side of the triangle is curved, which is why Nathan argues the globe is built on flat measurements.
North Is Not Up: The False Direction Fallacy
Nathan Oakley admits he mislabeled it the wrong direction fallacy in his book; the proper term is the false direction fallacy, where map makers ascribe vertical importance to a horizontal direction. His point is that north, south, east and west are azimuth, degrees measured in the horizontal from a leveled compass, and never up or down. He contends that the globe converts this directionality into verticality, which then requires the story of Theia striking Earth to deposit a molten iron core. Chance Garton notes that no one has ever observed a magnetically charged molten core, and that iron loses magnetism above the Curie point in the official model anyway.
Cognitively Expensive Nonsense Waffle
Chance Garton observes that every answer in the official cosmology leads to another baffling explanation, until cognitive fatigue makes people defer to the experts and accept they live in Narnia. Nathan Oakley credits YouTuber Ali Mc Forever with the phrase cognitively expensive, and argues that stacking layers of complicated backstory on a flat foundation is how a niche of enthusiasts becomes an authority nobody has time to question, while propaganda and state funded imagery keep the story feeling true. Both agree the simpler picture, that directions and distances are measured flat, sidesteps the whole apparatus, though Nathan says the chapter still leaves you understanding the heliocentric story better.
Fear, Speculation and Living Without It
In the second half Nathan Oakley argues that most propaganda and control efforts run on fear, and that recognizing how a deception was built lets you breathe easier; you still pay the mortgage, but you stop dreading a planet smashing into Earth. Chance Garton calls this worldview healing and says fear is a signal to find the lie beneath a belief. Asked about his own cosmology, Nathan declines to speculate, explaining that speculation becomes the target for mockery, while stating that the existence of God follows from ontological primitives and the laws of thermodynamics. He closes by saying life with his family and his channel could not be sweeter.
Quotes
“They hijack the terminology of an empirical method, science and the scientific method, to suggest that they've got proof and validity of fantasies of going into Narnia like sky vacuums with rockets.”
“What is important about this is none of that math works if any of those lines of that triangle are curved. Because then you don't have angles that add up to one hundred and eighty anymore.”
“How do you make a globe if Earth's flat? Well you derive radial values of circles with a fixed point called Polaris and then you can engineer a protractor view from within a globe that you can then project a map onto.”
“If you don't understand what I'm describing in base terms, grab a compass, level it, should be a hint. And then look where north is when you're trying to describe a degree from it for south, east, or west.”
“You ask one question, I don't understand how that works. So you gotta look into that. And you get another answer that is bewildering and baffling. So you gotta try to wrap your head around that.”
“The world isn't as scary as it first appears when you're being propagandized. Most propaganda and control efforts use fear to control you.”
“It's on you to recognize that the fear is a signal for you to find the lie and detach from it.”
“I hope people read Measured Flat and breathe easier after it. That is to say, they start to recognise the beauty of the world that they inhabit. And enjoy it for what it is. It's a very short lived experience that we get here.”
Nathan Oakley is the host of Flat Earth Debate, a daily live debate show on his YouTube channel Nathan Oakley 1980, where for roughly a decade he has invited the public in to argue the globe against what he calls flat Earth measurements. His approach sidesteps most of the familiar flat Earth arguments and focuses on geography and navigation: elevation angles, azimuth, celestial navigation and the conventions that build the globe model from measurements of a flat plane, framed through a series of housekeeping questions he puts to globe defenders. His first book, Measured Flat: All Roads Lead to Flat Earth, collects those arguments in one place.
See all Nathan episodes→Kyle and Serena Denton are community herbalists creating wild-crafted and organic plant medicines out of Milwaukee since 2015. I have used their teas and tinctures on an almost daily basis for years now. Kyle is a great friend of InnerVerse and has appeared on the channel more times than I can count. These products work, not in the allopathic "pharma-medicine" way, but in a terrain-support, consciousness bolstering plant-teacher sort of way.
